Clare Short
It's official - Saddam was not an imminent threat
Sat Aug 23 17:30:29 2003
64.140.158.165

Clare Short, MP: It's official - Saddam was not an imminent threat
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4521.htm

Hutton's remit was narrow - yet he has exposed the truth about the Iraq war

Clare Short

Saturday August 23, 2003: (The Guardian) After eight days of the Hutton inquiry and enormous quantities of media coverage, it is worth pausing to try to take stock. Many of us have said that, deliberately or otherwise, Alastair Campbell's decision to go to war with the BBC had the potential to distract attention from the most important questions arising from the Iraq crisis - whether the nation was deceived on the road to war, and where responsibility lies for the continuing chaos and loss of life in Iraq.

Lord Hutton has been charged with inquiring into the narrower question of the circumstances that led to the death of Dr David Kelly and will report on this very important question. But his inquiry is revealing important information that casts light on the bigger question of how we got to war.

There is an unfortunate tendency among some commentators to seek to narrow the issue to a blame game between the BBC and 10 Downing Street. This has led to comment to the effect that Dr Kelly was the unfortunate victim of a battle between two mighty institutions, accompanied by a campaign of vilification against Andrew Gilligan and the Today programme. It is important to remain constantly aware of the vested interests at play: the Murdoch empire and other rightwing media operations would like to weaken and break the BBC so that British broadcasting might be reduced to the sort of commercially dominated, biased news reporting that controls the US airwaves. It is extremely unfortunate that a Labour government has been willing to drive forward this campaign against the BBC.

We must not allow the barrage of biased comment to mislead us into a fudged conclusion that it was six of one and half a dozen of the other. And we must focus both on the pressures that were placed on Dr Kelly and the wider question of how we got to war in Iraq.

The inquiry has already established beyond doubt that, despite government briefing that Dr Kelly was a medium-level official of little significance, he was in fact one of the world's leading experts on WMD in Iraq. It is also clear that Dr Kelly chose to brief three BBC journalists - and presumably others - to the effect that the 45-minute warning of the possible use of WMD was an exaggeration. He said to the Newsnight reporter Susan Watts, as well as to Gilligan that Campbell and the Downing Street press operation were responsible for exerting pressure to hype up the danger. The inquiry is exploring the reality of that claim. But it is already clear that Dr Kelly made it, to Gilligan and Watts.

The BBC would have been grossly irresponsible if it had failed to bring such a report - from such an eminent source - to public attention. It is a delicious irony that Alastair Campbell castigates the BBC for relying on one very eminent source for this report ... and yet the 45-minute claim itself came from only one source.

As a result of the Hutton inquiry, we now know that two defence intelligence officials wrote to their boss to put on record their disquiet at the exaggeration in the dossier. Moreover, one official asked his boss for advice as to whether he should approach the foreign affairs select committee after the foreign secretary had said that he was not aware of any unhappiness among intelligence officials about the claims made in the dossier.

We know through emails revealed by Hutton that Tony Blair's chief of staff made clear that the dossier was likely to convince those who were prepared to be convinced, but that the document "does nothing to demonstrate he [Saddam Hussein] has the motive to attack his neighbours, let alone the west. We will need to be clear in launching the document that we do not claim that we have evidence that he is an imminent threat. The case we are making is that he has continued to develop WMD since 1998, and is in breach of UN resolutions. The international community has to enforce those resolutions if the UN is to be taken seriously."

I agree completely with Jonathan Powell's conclusion. But it follows from this that there was no need to truncate Dr Blix's inspection process and to divide the security council in order to get to war by a preordained date.

If there was no imminent threat, then Dr Blix could have been given the time he required. He may well have succeeded in ending all Iraq's WMD programmes - just as he succeeded in dismantling 60-plus ballistic missiles. Then sanctions could have been lifted and a concentrated effort made to help the people of Iraq end the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein - just as we did with Milosevic in Serbia.

Or if Blix had failed, we would have been in the position President Chirac described on March 10, when the issue would have come back to the security council. And in Chirac's view, this would have meant UN authorisation of military action.

The tragedy of all this is that if we had followed Jonathan Powell's conclusion, and the UK had used its friendship with the US to keep the world united on a UN route, then, even if it had come to war, a united international community under a UN mandate would almost certainly have made a better job of supporting Iraq's reconstruction. In this scenario the armed forces would have concentrated on keeping order; the UN humanitarian system would have fixed the water and electricity systems; Sergio Vieira de Mello, as Kofi Annan's special representative, would have helped the Iraqis to install an interim government and begin a process of constitutional change, as the UN has done in Afghanistan; and the World Bank and IMF would have advised the Iraqi interim authority on transparent economic reform, rather than a process of handover to US companies.

Following the terrible bombing of the UN headquarters in Baghdad, there is a danger that those who favour chaos in Iraq will make further gains, at great cost to the people of Iraq and coalition forces. The answer remains a stronger UN mandate and internationalisation of the reconstruction effort. The worry is that the US will not have the humility to ask for help, and the chaos and suffering will continue.

In the meantime, Lord Hutton will draw his conclusions about the tragic death of Dr Kelly. My own tentative conclusion is that Downing Street thought they could use him in their battle with the BBC, and that the power of the state was misused in a battle to protect the political interests of the government.

∑ Clare Short resigned as international development secretary in May

shortc@parliament.uk
-----------------------------
Three Troops Killed in Basra Attack:
Three British troops have been killed and one seriously wounded in an ambush in the southern Iraqi city of Basra.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/3175557.stm

===

Deal between Musharraf and U.S. on bin Laden?
Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf has struck a deal with the US not to capture Osama bin Laden, fearing this could lead to unrest in Pakistan.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4523.htm

===

Clare Short, MP: It's official - Saddam was not an imminent threat
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4521.htm

===

Emails show how No 10 constructed case for war:
The emails convey a frantic attempt to produce a dossier that will justify aggressive action against Saddam Hussein. Within the space of a fortnight - Mr Blair's aides turned British policy towards Iraq upside down.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4520.htm

===

Congressional Complicity in WMD Duplicity:
Why has Congress been relatively quiet on the executive branchís deception about Saddam Husseinís weapons of mass destruction? The answer is easy:
http://www.fff.org/comment/com0308k.asp

===

US sanctions on Syria ' could come soon':
Eliot Engel, a key sponsor of the bill, said that he had received strong support for the legislation from Ariel Sharon after meeting the Israeli Prime Minister in Jerusalem.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4522.htm

===

Canada Arrests 19 in Case with 9/11 Parallels:
The Toronto Star newspaper said the men were arrested after a "pattern of suspicious behavior" which featured one man taking flight lessons that took him directly over an Ontario nuclear power plant.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=578&ncid=578&e=3&u=/nm/20030822/ts_nm/crime_canada_dc

===

Six al-Qaeda support groups being tracked within US: report:
US law enforcement officers are tracking six groups with suspected links to al-Qaeda within the United States, and see a "widening presence" of al-Qaeda sympathisers on US soil.
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/08/23/1061529382017.html

===

US, Finds Britain Its Lone Supporter:
America's campaign to rally more support for its occupation of Iraq at the United Nations ran into early opposition last night, leaving Britain as its only powerful ally.
http://tinyurl.com/kxmj

===

Bush "Islam's biggest enemy":
http://www.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,4057,7050272^1702,00.html

===


Military Mute On Vaccine Danger?
As long as the military controls the data on soldiers who've gotten sick after their vaccinations, it may be impossible to ever know the whole story.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/08/21/eveningnews/main569522.shtml

===

Fox Loses Bid to Stop Sale of Franken Book :
A federal judge on Friday slammed Fox News' trademark infringement lawsuit against Al Franken and his publisher Penguin Group and refused to stop the sale of the liberal satirist's new book that pokes fun at the network and host Bill O'Reilly.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A33568-2003Aug22?

===

A Country Liberated: Humor
http://www.markfiore.com/animation/liberation.html

===

Jewish terror suspect allegedly already carried out attacks
http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/spages/332361.html

===

A land without Arabs:
Israel's policy of land grab turns viable neighbourhoods into ghost towns.
http://weekly.ahram.org.eg/2003/652/re1.htm

===

Six killed in fighting in Afghanistan
http://www.globeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20030823.wafghan0823/BNStory/International/

===

Seven days of terror in world at war:
Last week, from August 17 to yesterday, more than 150 people died in terror-related incidents worldwide.
http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/08/23/1061529377783.html

===

A Must Listen
Greg Palast on the Real Reasons for Blackout 2003:
What are you going to do with a slightly used President? A Must Listen
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4519.htm

===

In the Cross Hairs:
There were several warning signs that the United Nations could soon be in the cross hairs of the forces battling the American-led coalition in Iraq.
http://tinyurl.com/kyoj

===

Australian case for Iraq war was ' fabricated':
The Australian government "skewed, misrepresented, used selectively and fabricated" the intelligence used to justify its decision to send troops to Iraq, a parliamentary inquiry in Canberra was told yesterday.
http://news.independent.co.uk/world/australasia/story.jsp%3Fstory%3D436350

===

New UN resolution: deploying more troops in Iraq unlikely: Annan
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/middleeast/view/47433/1/.html

===

Bush Appoints Daniel Pipes to Think Tank:
President Bush bypassed the Senate Friday and appointed an outspoken Middle East "scholar" to a federal think tank over the objections of Democrats and others who say he is anti-Muslim.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uslatest/story/0,1282,-3059833,00.html

Click here for Background on Pipes
http://tinyurl.com/juez
.
===

US Launching New-Look Military Strike Force:
In another sign of what military officials call the "transformation" of the U.S. military, seven Navy ships are set to depart today for the western Pacific carrying 2,200 combat Marines, more than 100 Tomahawk missiles and a squadron of helicopters and vertical-lift Harrier attack planes.
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-force22aug22,1,6881579.story?coll=la-headlines-nation

===

US Considers Accepting North Korean Refugees:
The United States is considering allowing North Koreans who have fled to China to seek refugee status and asylum in the U.S., a senior U.S. official in charge of human rights issues said Wednesday.
http://www.japantimes.com/cgi-bin/getarticle.pl5?nn20030822a1.htm

===

This site is 100% reader supported. Click here If You Can Help To Support Our Efforts
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/support.htm

===

Israel Threatens Big Military Offensive:
"If in a few days we think it is completely hopeless, we will take much more serious action."
http://news.ft.com/servlet/ContentServer?pagename=FT.com/StoryFT/FullStory&c=StoryFT&cid=1059479251566&p=1012571727172

===


Both Sides Vow Revenge as Peace Plan Collapses:
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/08/22/1061529339585.html

==

Islamic Militants Call for Revenge at Hamas Leader's Funeral
http://www.nytimes.com/reuters/international/international-mideast.html?ex=1062579818&ei=1&en=06f91a260dc401e0

===

War Leaders Face the Music on Homefront:
More than three months after President George W. Bush stood in front of a banner reading "Mission Accomplished" on the USS Abraham Lincoln, the three leaders who planned the invasion of Iraq are this weekend confronting continuing challenges arising from the war.
http://news.ft.com/servlet/ContentServer?pagename=FT.com/StoryFT/FullStory&c=StoryFT&cid=1059479255108&p=1012571727088

===

Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity:
What Happens When You Remain Silent?
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4518.htm

===

Sudan Embassy: Time for the United States to Take Responsibility:
For The 1998 American Attack on the Al-Shifa Medicine Factory. The U.S. Administration has to date failed to compensate the victim, apologize to the Sudanese people or rebuild the plant, an act which would have shown sense of morality in international relations.
http://releases.usnewswire.com/GetRelease.asp?id=138-08192003

===

Ashcroft Speech Interrupted by Protester:
A room packed with police officers failed to shield Attorney General John Ashcroft on Thursday from a protester who accused him of lying about the Sept. 11 attacks on America and Washington's declared war on terror.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/nm/20030821/pl_nm/security_ashcroft_dc

===
Liberty can not be preserved without general knowledge among people." (August 1765) John Adams


Main Page - Saturday, 08/23/03

Message Board by American Patriot Friends Network [APFN]

APFN MESSAGEBOARD ARCHIVES

messageboard.gif (4314 bytes)