ABA Loosens Attorney-Client Secrecy Rules
Tue Aug 12 14:24:35 2003
ABA Loosens Attorney-Client Secrecy Rules
Monday, August 11, 2003; 10:27 PM
By Gail Appleson, Law Correspondent
SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - The American Bar Association on Monday narrowly passed
a controversial proposal that will allow lawyers to pierce sacred
attorney-client secrecy rules to help stop financial crimes.
In a 218 to 201 vote, the ABA's policy-making body amended its ethics code to
allow, but not require, lawyers to breach attorney-client privilege if they
believe doing so would stop a client from committing a financial crime or fraud.
Dennis Archer, the ABA's incoming president, urged passage of the amendment.
"This is in the best interest of our profession. It is in the best interest of
our country," said Archer, a former mayor of Detroit.
Many lawyers objected to the change, fearing it would severely harm the
time-honored duty of lawyers to keep a client's information secret. They also
worry that the change could expose lawyers to liability lawsuits.
Among them was president-elect Robert Gray of Richmond, Virginia, who will
succeed Archer in August 2004.
"This is not the proper time to bow to threats by those who seek to regulate
us," Gray said. "This not a time to take a position that the core values of this
profession are subject to compromise."
The group is scheduled to vote on another controversial ethics amendment on
Tuesday that applies to lawyers who represent corporate clients. The proposal
clarifies "triggers" that would require lawyers to report a corporate officer's
conduct to the company's upper management. It also addresses circumstances in
which lawyers can reveal information to authorities about their corporate
Similar proposals have been defeated by the House of Delegates in previous
years. However, Archer and many other lawyers feel the landscape has changed in
the wake of high-profile scandals that have engulfed Enron and other companies.
"The environment we are in is very sobering," said William Ide, a former ABA
president from Atlanta. "As officers of the court it is our responsibility to
take a hard look at the damages that have been done to people. We need to decide
there is more lawyers can do."
Indeed, the ABA's vote will be closely watched by the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission, which has been charged by Congress with setting standards
of professional conduct for in-house and outside attorneys who advise public
Some SEC rules for lawyers went into effect last week, and the agency could
adopt more stringent requirements if it is dissatisfied with the ABA's actions.
However, several lawyers spoke out against the proposal, including William Paul,
a former ABA president from Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, who said the rule change
undermines a system that has worked for some 200 years.
"We need that rule to enable us to do our work," he said, adding that the
amendment "asks us to barter away a piece of our professional soul to get some
hope for public approval."
Sharon Stern Gerstman of Buffalo, New York, said the recent corporate scandals
were not caused by lawyers' inability to reveal confidences and there is "not
one shred of evidence" that the rule change would have made a difference.
Instead, she said the ABA is being pressured by "government agencies that want
us to make their jobs of learning our clients' secrets easier for them."
Welcome to the American Bar Association
Thank You for visiting the American Bar Association. The ABA website
Searched the web for APFN LAW.
... Secret Courts - Secret Law
An Oath is an Oath is an Oath
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/thelaw.htm - 27k - Cached - Similar pages
Secret Courts - Secret Law
... htm. The Law!
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/thelaw.htm. The Declaration
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/declaration.htm. Recind ...
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/secretcourts.htm - 22k - Cached - Similar pages
... Also discovered is that we have law in Alaska by Legal Notice only - another
IS NOT A BUSINESS APFN IS SUPPORTED BY "FREE WILL" GIFT/DONATIONS Without ...
http://www.apfn.net/ - 21k -
Cached - Similar pages
SECT 861:... THE LAW THEY HOPE YOU NEVER READ
... Because most Americans are ignorant of the law, they have been unwittingly
their own chains. ... APFN-1 YahooGroups: Subscribe:
http://www.apfn.net/messageboard/6-19-03/ discussion.cgi.62.html - 11k
Martial law is coming -- one city at a time John Hammell, Tue Aug 12 14:34
ID chips pressed into laundered clothes ZDNet UK, Tue Aug 12 17:52
Main Page -
Message Board by American
Patriot Friends Network [APFN]