Ruth Rosen
AN EXECUTIVE ORDER - As ordered, it's about oil
Sat Aug 9 22:08:27 2003
64.140.159.159

As ordered, it's about oil

AN EXECUTIVE ORDER can be a surreptitious way of making policy. It often makes an end-run around Congress and frequently escapes the media's attention as well. It is, in short, a way of making policy by fiat.

President Bush has signed a slew of executive orders that have gone unreported for weeks or months -- most notably, changes to environmental regulations and restricted access to former presidential papers and Freedom of Information Act information.

Now, a potentially explosive executive order has just been discovered by SEEN, the Sustainable Energy and Economy Network. Signed on May 22, it appears to give U.S. oil companies in Iraq blanket immunity from lawsuits and criminal prosecution.

Here's what happened: On May 22, the U.N. Security Council passed Resolution 1438, which provided gas and oil companies in Iraq with limited immunity until Dec. 21, 2007. Their reason? To protect the flow of oil revenues into the development fund that will be used to reconstruct Iraq. The U.N. resolution, however, did not provide immunity from human rights violations or environmental damage. Nor did it protect any employee or any company after the oil was produced and extracted in Iraq.

Notice what President Bush changed when, on the same day, he issued Executive Order 13303 -- called "Protecting the Development Fund and Certain Other Property in Which Iraq Has an Interest." Unlike the U.N. resolution, the president's order appears to place U.S. corporations above the law for any activities related to Iraq oil, either in that country or in the United States.

It also declared a national emergency as the justification for sweeping aside all federal statues, including the Alien Tort Claims Act, and appears to provide immunity against contractual disputes, discrimination suits, violations of labor practices, international treaties, environmental disasters and human rights violations. Even more, it doesn't limit immunity to the production of oil, but also protects individuals, companies and corporations involved in selling and marketing the oil as well.

Unlike the U.N. resolution, therefore, the order provides immunity for more of the industry's activities, as well as for a broader swath of individuals, companies and corporations.

These are the kind of legal protections that most corporations could only dream of enjoying. If, for example, a U.S. oil company engages in criminal behavior in California, and its assets can be traced back to Iraqi oil, it could be immune from any kind of prosecution.

Tellingly, the president's order provides no such legal immunity for companies who are helping to reconstruct Iraqi communications, computer or electrical infrastructure.

"In terms of legal liability," said Tom Devine, legal director of the Government Accountability Project, a Washington nonprofit group that defends whistle blowers, "the executive order cancels the concept of corporate accountability and abandons the rule of law. It is a blank check for corporate anarchy, potentially robbing Iraqis of both their rights and their resources."

Taylor Griffin, a spokesman for the Treasury Department, told me that this is a "tortured and incorrect reading of the executive order and what it hopes to achieve: protecting the revenue that belongs to the Iraqi people." When asked why the order did not exempt human rights or environmental damage, he responded, "When the regulations are written, they will address these."

But Betsy Apple, managing director and an attorney with EarthRights International, a Washington, D.C., human rights organization, thinks this is disingenuous and described the executive order as "an outrage" in a telephone interview. "It is a green light for oil companies to do business in Iraq, without worrying about legal liability," she said.

For some critics, the executive order supports the suspicion that the invasion of Iraq was always about gaining control of that country's oil. Jim Vallette, senior researcher at the liberal Institute for Policy Studies, said, "This order reveals the true motivation for the present occupation: absolute power for U.S. corporate interest over Iraqi oil."

The Institute and the Government Accountability Project have now asked Congress to investigate -- and repeal -- this order. The president's order is an outrage and Congress should act immediately. In our democracy, no one is above the law.

E-mail Ruth Rosen at rrosen@sfchronicle.com

-----------------------------------------------------


Search sponsors add search to your site

Find more results for ENRON BUSH on Web Search.com Web Search multiple engines for "Enron bush" and get fast results you can compare with one click.
Webmasters - Add a search engine to your site Advanced search and navigation technology can be added to your web site in minutes. Get high speed, high availability, hosted search technology from th...
Kazaa Plus - download free MP3 or text files on everything imaginable. Kazaa Plus - download free MP3 or text files on everything imaginable. Search for any person, place or thing on the worl...


Search Results From This Site
Found 104 items, now showing 1 - 10 search tips site map

>
NewRefineWeb
1. The Story of ENRON
The Story of ENRON "The story of Enron is the story of unmitigated ... THE COLLAPSE OF ENRON WASHINGTON - 12.18.01 - Following ... collapse of the Enron Corporation. Dorgan, Chairman of
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/enron.htm

2. Text of Sherron Watkins' Testimony at House Hearing on Enron
at House Hearing on Enron American Hero Sherron Watkins February 14, 2002 ... House Hearing on Enron The following is the text of ... collapse of the Enron Corporation, as recorded by the
http://www.apfn.org/enron/watkins2.htm

3. The Enron Collapse And The Bush/Republican Connections!
The Enron Collapse And The Bush/Republican Connections ! This is The ... scheduled on the Enron scandal. In the legislature, reduced ... W. Bush's turn. Enron, a gigantic Texan energy
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/enron_republican.htm

4. ENRON-BUSH-HARVARD-WTC-OIL-CONNECTION
PROOF ENRON-BUSH-HARVARD-WTC-OIL-CONNECTION REPORT OF ... OF DIRECTORS OF ENRON CORP. February 1, 2002 ENRON GAVE TALIBAN $MILLIONS Enron-FedGov Corruption: CIA Used in
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/enron_bush.htm

5. BUSH'S ENRONGATE
TPJ's report on the Enron Corp.'s political money trail, at www.tpj.org/Lobby_Watch/enron.html. The report catalogs the ... largesse (George W. Bush, Gov. Rick Perry, John Cornyn
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enrongate.htm

6. ENRON'S Jeffery K. Skilling
http://www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf  http://www.cera.com  ... President and COO, Enron Corp.; becomes CEO on Feb ... station INTRODUCTION TO ENRON Joined McKinsey & Co. after Harvard
http://www.apfn.org/ENRON/skilling.htm

7. IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DIVISION The principal Enron defendant named in the Complaint is the Enron Corporation, an Oregon corporation which ... Texas (see www.Enron.com ). The other Enron defendants are: Mary
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enron_court.htm

8. Ex-Enron vice chair commits suicide
Ex-Enron vice chair commits suicide J. Clifford Baxter resigned from Enron Corp. He will continue to work for ... msn&cp1=1 Ex-Enron vice chair commits suicide . Clifford Baxter
http://www.apfn.org/enron/suicide.htm

9. MORE ON: ENRON'S Herbert S. "Pug" Winokur, Jr.
Oregon Vice Chairman, Enron Corp., Chairman and CEO, Portland ... and Chairman of Enron Communications Robert K. Jaedicke (2* ... Chairman and CEO, Enron Corp. Charles A. LeMaistre (1
http://www.apfn.org/enron/winokur2.htm

10. ENRON'S Herbert S. Winokur, Jr.
is a Director of Enron Corp., Mrs. Fields' Famous Brands, Inc., ... www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf  Enron's Pug Winokur ... POWER SCAM: THE ENRON BUSH CONNECTION By: Uri Dowbenko The
http://www.apfn.org/enron/winokur.htm

11. Tauzin, Greenwood Want Documents From Enron
Want Documents From Enron, Additional Meetings With Senior Company ... have called on Enron Corporation to turn over specific ... letters sent to Enron Chairman and Chief Executive
http://www.apfn.org/enron/committee.htm

12. R. I. C. O. LAWSUIT AGAINST G. W. BUSH
Lawsuit Against G.W. Bush [The actual lawsuit has not yet been ... Lawsuit Against G.W. Bush Thu Apr 24 12:05:37 2003 ... v. GEORGE W. BUSH, President of the United States
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/RICO_bush.htm

13. ENRON'S Herbert S. Winokur, Jr.
is a Director of Enron Corp., Mrs. Fields' Famous Brands, Inc., ... www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf  Enron's Pug Winokur ... POWER SCAM: THE ENRON BUSH CONNECTION By: Uri Dowbenko The
http://www.apfn.org/enron/winokur.htm ?
Who%20is%20Herbert

14. ENRON'S Jeff McMahon
www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf ENRON NAMES JEFF McMAHON CHIEF FINANCIAL ... 24, 2001 HOUSTON Enron Corp. announced today that it ... and CEO of Enron s Industrial Markets group. From
http://www.apfn.org/enron/mcmahon.htm

15. ENRON'S Wendy L. Gramm
shares for $276,912. ENRON: Wendy L. Gramm: Washington , D.C. Former ... http://www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf Wendy Gramm and Bush officials to Enron fiasco, Ca crisis Sat Jan
http://www.apfn.org/enron/gramm.htm

16. ENRON'S Richard A. Causey
Chief Accounting Officer Enron Richard A. Causey is executive ... accounting officer of Enron. Previously, Mr. Causey was a managing director of Enron Capital & Trade Resources (ECT)
http://www.apfn.org/enron/causey.htm

17. HOW TO CREATE A PHONY POWER CRISIS: THE BUSH-ENRON CONNECTION
PHONY POWER CRISIS: THE BUSH-ENRON CONNECTION By Uri Dowbenko February 2, 2001 ... ties to the Bush Family. One of the prime ... the "crisis" is Enron Corporation and its chairman, Ken
http://www.apfn.org/enron/phoney.htm

18. ENRON'S Rebecca P. Mark
that time, she joined Enron Corp. in 1982, became executive vice president of Enron Power Corp. in 1986, chairman and CEO of Enron Development Corp. in 1991, chairman and
http://www.apfn.org/enron/mark.htm

19. Enron put Bush in White House
Enron put Bush in White House Enron put Bush in White House http://www ... President George W. Bush s clumsy attempts to distance himself from Enron Corporation. McDonald pointed out
http://www.apfn.org/enron/whitehouse.htm

20. Army secretary Juggles Enron, Troops
Army Secretary Juggles Enron, Troops Army Secretary Juggles Enron, Troops Thu Mar 28, 2 ... his previous employer, Enron Corp., pull him too much ... The former Enron executive said he is
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/enron_white.htm

21. Tracking "Pug" Winokur, wolf in the Enron fold
Winokur, wolf in the Enron fold Tracking "Pug" Winokur, wolf in the Enron fold By Larry Chin Online Journal Contributing ... been devoted to the Enron fix, which is quickly becoming one
http://www.apfn.org/enron/tracking_winokur.htm

22. ENRON'S Kenneth L. Lay
http://www.apfn.org/ENRON/Blind_Faith.pdf KENNETH L. LAY Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Enron Corp. Kenneth L. Lay is ... Executive Officer of Enron Corp. He was named to
http://www.apfn.org/ENRON/lay.htm

23. Enron-FedGov Corruption: CIA Used in Corp Espionage, Rackets
Enron-FedGov Corruption: CIA Used in Corp Espionage, Rackets ENRON: THE UNTOLD STORY Published on: February ... the scandal-plagued Enron Corporation secretly employed CIA agents
http://www.apfn.org/enron/fedgov.htm

24. Williams Companies: Enron II
Williams Companies: Enron II Williams Companies: Enron II By Wayne Madsen Special ... it made with Enron. However, a few weeks ... that bankrupted Enron. Although Williams executives
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enron2.htm

25. William C. Powers, Jr.
wpowers/about.html  ============================================================================ ENRON Board of Directors Robert A ... Corporation http://www.enron.com/corp/pressroom/board
http://www.apfn.org/enron/powers.htm

26. ENRON'S Joseph W. Sutton
for $40 million. ENRON PROMOTES JOSEPH SUTTON TO ... www.apfn.org/enron/ENRON.htm   =========================================================== Joseph W ... Board Former Enron Vice Chairman Brings
http://www.apfn.org/enron/sutton.htm

27. Bush and Cheney are from the same state
Coxnews | Campaign 2000 | News Bush and Cheney are from the same state ... com To: apfn@apfn.org Bush and Cheney are from the same ... Read this George Bush received 32 electoral votes for
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/2000.htm

28. ENRON'S James V. Derrick
President and General Counsel Enron Corp. James V. Derrick, Jr. was ... general counsel of Enron in July 1999. Previously, Mr ... Committee. Before joining Enron, Mr. Derrick had been in
http://www.apfn.org/enron/derrick.htm

29. Pentagon Official From Enron in Hot Seat
Pentagon Official From Enron in Hot Seat Questions Raised About Army ... part because the Bush administration wanted to bring business ... year executive with Enron Corp. and a 23-year
http://www.apfn.org/enron/hot_seat.htm

30. Sherron Watkins - Woman Who Saw Red
red Portrait of the Enron whistle-blower who warned of the trouble ... of vice president at Enron, she owned a lovely home in an ... who had warned Enron s now-former chairman, Kenneth
http://www.apfn.org/enron/Sherron_watkins.htm

31. CHANDRA LEVY: UNRAVELING GOVERNMENT COVERUPS?
Chandra Levy Saves GW Bush What an amazing coincidence! Chandra Levy's body ... about what the Bush administration knew before 9/11. ... all questions about Bush right out of the news
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/chandra_levy.htm

32. ENRON GAVE TALIBAN $MILLIONS
ENRON GAVE TALIBAN $MILLIONS ENRON GAVE TALIBAN $MILLIONS The Enron Corporation gave the Taliban millions ... Osama Bin Laden! Enron executives even met with ... of the Enron money wound up
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/WTC_millions.htm

33. Enron Executives
Enron Executives Board of Directors Robert A. Belfer ... Chairman Michael Brown, COO, Enron Europe Richard B. Buy, Exec. VP, ... Chairman and CEO, Enron Energy James V. Derrick, Jr
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enron_exec.htm

34. Enron utilized tax loopholes in Caymans haven
ENRON'S SECOND HOME Enron utilized tax loopholes in Caymans haven Enron utilized tax loopholes in Caymans ... one subsidiary each, Enron set up nearly 700. Enron also found a tax
http://www.apfn.org/enron/cayman.htm

35. Order by Justice Department links Bush administration to Enron probe
Justice Department links Bush administration to Enron probe Feb. 2, 2002 ... to retain Enron-related documents, linking the Bush administration and the ... investigation of Enron for the first
http://www.apfn.org/enron/order.htm

36. Enron Reps Met With Cheney 6 Time
Enron Reps Met With Cheney 6 Times January 8, 2002 Enron Reps Met With Cheney 6 Times By THE ... m. ET WASHINGTON (AP) -- Enron Corp. representatives met six times with Vice
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enron_cheney.htm

37. USA: Enron Got Its Money's Worth
USA: Enron Got Its Money's Worth USA: Enron Got Its Money's Worth Look No Further ... by apologists for the Bush administration is that while Enron may have bankrolled much of the
http://www.apfn.org/enron/enron_money.htm

38. Enron and the Corporate States of America
Enron and the Corporate States of America Enron and the Corporate States of America By Bev ... between those scandals and Enron. The Enron scandal was carried into the White House
http://www.apfn.org/enron/corporate.htm

39. WTC-911 - THE BASIC QUESTIONS
was George H. W. Bush at the time of the attacks? 6 ... discontinued? 9. How did Bush see the first plane crash on live ... 22. Why did .Bush stop inquiries into terrorist connections of
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/WTC_questions.htm

40. WTC-911 - THE BASIC QUESTIONS
was George H. W. Bush at the time of the attacks? 6 ... discontinued? 9. How did Bush see the first plane crash on live ... 22. Why did .Bush stop inquiries into terrorist connections of
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/WTC_questions.htm 

• Who Are the Terrorists? — APFN, Sat Aug 9 22:49
• Air Force Officer Delivers Blistering Excoriation of Bush — Jerry Isaacs, Sat Aug 9 23:42
• Has Blair Sexed Up Saddam's Atrocities, Too? — John Laughland, Sat Aug 9 23:27