FBI chief errs on Patriot Act provision
Sat Mar 31, 2007 18:50

FBI chief errs on Patriot Act provision

By MICHAEL J. SNIFFEN, Associated Press WriterFri Mar 30, 7:22 PM ET

AP Photo: In this April 5, 2005, file photo, FBI Director Robert Mueller testifies on the reauthorization...

FBI Director Robert Mueller blames poor training and supervision for the bureau's Patriot Act abuses and promises new training programs. He might want to sign up for the first class himself.

Mueller misstated a key provision of the act in appealing to Congress this week for new authority that was actually granted last year.

"I think he was using old talking points," joked Georgetown law professor Viet Dinh, who drafted the original Patriot Act in 2001 while serving in the Justice Department.

The director's gaffe came during a high-stakes moment for the FBI and for him.

Justice Department Inspector General Glenn Fine found 48 violations of law or rules during 2003-2005 in the bureau's use of documents known as national security letters to acquire telephone, e-mail and financial records about Americans and foreigners without a judge's approval.

Fine estimated there could be 3,000 more such violations among the more than 143,000 requests for information during that period.

At a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing Tuesday, Mueller labored to persuade skeptical senators that they didn't need to reduce the bureau's authority under the Patriot Act to fix the problems.

He emphasized that the inspector general found no intentional violations but instead attributed them to "mistakes, carelessness, confusion, sloppiness, lack of training, lack of adequate guidance and lack of adequate oversight."

Mueller assured senators he could curb the violations by providing better training and supervision, among other steps. And he shouldered some blame himself, particularly for not instituting compliance audits to be sure proper procedures were being followed.

Then Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (news, bio, voting record), D-R.I., asked him if it would be useful to adopt some procedures used for issuing administrative subpoenas, which agents can use to demand records in health care fraud or drug diversion cases without prior judicial approval.

"I would give up NSLs for administrative subpoenas," Mueller responded. "I say that because, in the regime of administrative subpoenas, there is generally opportunity for the recipient to contest it in court, on a variety of reasons. But there also is the opportunity for the government to enforce it in court. We do not have an enforcement mechanism for national security letters."

But the reauthorization of the Patriot Act a year ago provided just such an enforcement mechanism. It said that if a company refused to deliver the requested records, the Justice Department could get a federal court order requiring compliance and contempt of court penalties for further resistance.

"He misspoke," said FBI spokesman John Miller. "He was operating on the standard that existed before the renewal where the enforcement mechanism was not clearly defined." Miller added that Mueller knows the law was changed, but "it just slipped his mind for that moment."

James Dempsey, policy director of the Center for Democracy and Technology, a civil liberties group that wants prior judicial approval for the letters, thought the error undercut some of Mueller's case.

"The FBI director doesn't know the law that he's enforcing," Dempsey said. The inspector general and Mueller are arguing that this is a problem of poorly trained lower level agents, "and the guy responsible for implementing the law and the inspector general's recommendations still doesn't understand the law."

Mueller's statement would have been accurate before the Patriot Act renewal.

Although not widely known, before then, if the FBI sent a national security letter demanding records, the recipient was free to ignore the request. Not that that was a big problem.

"Only the librarians ever fought them," said Dempsey. "No bank or telephone company would say `no' when an agent comes in and says this is needed for a national security investigation."

The FBI dropped its request for records of a computer at a Connecticut library after the librarians resisted last year.

National security letters, first authorized in 1986, can be used to acquire e-mail, telephone and travel records and financial information, such as credit and bank transactions.

In 2001, the Patriot Act eliminated any requirement that the records belong to someone under suspicion. Now an innocent person's records can be obtained if FBI field agents consider them relevant to a terrorism or spying investigation.


On the Net:

Federal Bureau of Investigation:


FBI Offers Reward For Shauntay Henderson
KMBC via Yahoo! News Fri, 30 Mar 2007 3:44 PM PDT
The FBI is offering a reward for tips leading to the arrest of one of the city's most wanted suspects.

FBI releases Emmett Till autopsy results, discusses investigation
ABC 15 Phoenix Sat, 31 Mar 2007 8:52 AM PDT
CHICAGO (AP) - The FBI has released a 464-page report that contains gruesome details about the autopsy of Emmitt Till, the black teen-ager killed in Mississippi in 1955 for whistling at a white woman.

Reynolds Graduates From FBI Academy
The Morning News Sat, 31 Mar 2007 1:01 AM PDT
Fayetteville Police Capt. Mike Reynolds graduated from the FBI National Academy Program on March 16.

FBI-ISU start joint program
Idaho State Journal Fri, 30 Mar 2007 10:45 PM PDT
POCATELLO ? Local members of the FBI celebrated the opening of a new transcription center with a ribbon cutting ceremony March 29 at the Pocatello Information and Technology Center in Pocatello.

FBI releases Emmett Till autopsy, discusses probe with relatives
KATC 3 Lafayette Fri, 30 Mar 2007 8:54 PM PDT
CHICAGO -- A 464-page FBI report released Friday contains gruesome details from the autopsy of Emmett Till, but it is so highly redacted that it doesn't shed much light on the teen's...

FBI releases Emmett Till autopsy, discusses probe with relatives
The Daily Comet Fri, 30 Mar 2007 8:41 PM PDT
A 464-page FBI report released Friday contains gruesome details from the autopsy of Emmett Till, but it is so highly redacted that it doesn't shed much light on the teen's killing, which helped galvanize the civil rights movement.

FBI: Antiquities Found Inside Berwyn Home
CBS 2 Chicago Fri, 30 Mar 2007 8:12 PM PDT
The FBI released new information Friday about the hidden treasure found inside a Berwyn home. CBS 2's Rafael Romo reports on the house that may contain Vatican antiquities. VIDEO: Hear An Antiques Dealer Who Has Been Inside The Home Describe The Collection

FBI arrests 2 of Indian origin, accuses 2 Indian govt officials in sale of missile tech
Indian Express via Yahoo! India News Fri, 30 Mar 2007 2:48 PM PDT
The United States Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has arrested two persons of Indian origin running an electronics company in South Carolina and referred to two unnamed Indian government officials as "co-conspirators" in the alleged export of sensitive dual-use items from the US to three Indian entities: Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre (VSSC) for possible use in production of missiles and ...

Main Page - Saturday, 04/07/07

Message Board by American Patriot Friends Network [APFN]


messageboard.gif (4314 bytes)