"Audio Music Man 1962" in Music - PerformancesSun May 20, 2007 19:01
"Audio Music Man 1962" in Music - Performances -
Clips by apfnorg
The Music Man (Special Edition) (1962)
Starring: Robert Preston, Shirley Jones, Ron Howard
Director: Morton DaCosta
34 out of 47 people found the following comment useful:-
The BEST adaptation of a Broadway musical to film., 19 April 2000
Author: Arne Andersen ( firstname.lastname@example.org ) from Putney, VT
I will go on record to say that THE MUSIC MAN is the BEST film adaptation of a Broadway musical. Unlike MY FAIR LADY (another fine acievement) which was translated almost verbatim from the stage libretto to film, THE MUSIC MAN is NOT that great a musical comedy on stage. In fact, it's pretty mediocre. Comparing the original stage libretto to what Marion Hargrove did with her incredible screenplay, one counts over forty additional scenes or pieces of dialogue that open out and/ or add character to the principals. Her screenplay is such a VAST improvement over the original it is truly what makes the film so special. A number of reviewers on this site loathe the film, but I imagine they would loathe any musical. This is top rate acting, singing, dancing, with fast paced direction and a constantly moving camera for the dance numbers - the absolute best mise en scene I've ever experienced in a filmed musical comedy. (Mind you, musical play adaptations are a different category - I'm talking musical comedies here). Get the letterboxed version if you can as this was beautifully composed for wide screen. I remember seeing it in the balmy summer days of one of our nation's last years of innocence. Everyone was seeing it, talking about it, theaters extending their runs for a number of months to early autumn. It brought together all the nostalgia of what we best remember of another golden era (just before WW I) when America was still basically an agrarian economy. A real gem, this one.
5/20/07 OTHER "RADIO YOUR WAY"
RADIO YOUR WAY
Main Page - Friday, 05/30/07
Message Board by American Patriot Friends Network [APFN]
APFN MESSAGEBOARD ARCHIVES